The Xenophile Historian

63 B.C. to 226 A.D.

	Rome vs. Parthia
	Herod the Great
	The Tetrarchy
	Prelude to the New Testament
	The Birth of Christianity
	The Journeys of the Apostles
	The Last Herods
	The Jewish-Roman War
	Parthia: The Anti-Hellenistic Period
	Bar Kochba's Revolt
	Commerce Under the Pax Romana
	The Two Empires in Trouble
	The End of the Parthians
	Go to Page Navigator

This was the situation when three men, known to us as the First Triumvirate, seized power from the Roman Senate. We met one of them, Pompey, in the previous chapter; the others were Julius Caesar and Marcus Licinius Crassus. The oldest and richest of the triumvirs, Crassus became governor of Syria in 55 B.C. Pompey had conquered the Levant and Caesar had conquered Gaul, so Crassus wanted to be a conquering hero, too. Against the protests of cooler heads in Rome, he decided that his victims would be the Parthians. First he got the money to pay for his expedition, by going to Jerusalem and confiscating everything of value he could find in the Jewish Temple. When he approached the Euphrates late in 54 B.C., the new Parthian king, Orodes II, first protested that Crassus was breaking all the treaties signed between Parthia and Rome. Then he sent an ambassador, who asked whether Crassus was marching on orders from Rome (in which case they would oppose him with everything they had), or if the invasion was his idea (in which case they would pity him for his senility). Crassus replied that he would give his answer in Seleucia. The ambassador, perhaps mindful of the first emissary who took insults from Rome, held out his hand and exclaimed, "Hair, Crassus, will grow on my palm before you see Seleucia."

Marcus Licinius Crassus.

Crassus was killed at Carrhae, but the details are not clear. In the middle of the battle he saw a Parthian ride by, carrying the head of his son; no doubt that ruined his day. As for what happened to Crassus himself, the most popular story is that the Parthians captured him alive, and they cured his thirst for gold by pouring molten gold down his throat! Crassus did earn for himself a place in history--as the worst general the ancient world ever produced. It took a generation for Rome to get over the disaster at Carrhae.

Surenas enjoyed his triumph briefly; Orodes distrusted generals who can beat 4:1 odds and had him murdered. Now that the time looked ripe, he assigned his son Pacorus the task of depriving the Romans of Syria. However, Pacorus was an inexperienced youth at this point, and the Parthian army, despite the improvements made, was still poor at organizing long campaigns or taking fortified cities. After a raid failed, Pacorus launched a major invasion in 51 B.C., this time capturing and holding all of Syria for several months. He had to give it back, however, when he was falsely accused of treason; Orodes recalled and nearly executed his son. As Orodes quarreled with Pacorus and Caesar quarreled with Pompey, the Syrian war petered out. Armenia and two tribes in the Caucasus (the Iberians and the Albani) passed out of Roman control, but a decade passed before Parthia got a chance to invade the west again.

The war zone, where Rome, Parthia and Armenia met.

A leader in the conspiracy against Caesar was Gaius Cassius Longinus, the general who had defeated the Parthians in the first campaign of Pacorus. Cassius proclaimed himself proconsul of Syria, and put Antipater, the Idumaean noble from the previous chapter, in charge of Israel. Cassius began to raise an army to fight the new rulers of Rome, the Second Triumvirate, and Antipater was given the task of gathering the money needed for the project. Resentment against Antipater resulted in his poisoning by Malichus, a man who posed as a friend of Antipater while planning to seize the government for himself. One year later (42 B.C.), two members of the Second Triumvirate, Mark Antony and Octavian, defeated and killed Cassius in Macedonia.

Mark Antony inherited Caesar's Parthian project. Pacorus, however, acted first, by concluding an agreement with Quintus Labienus, an officer among Caesar's assassins who went over to the Parthians to avoid being arrested. In 40 B.C. they invaded Rome's Asian territories with startling success: Labienus took all of Asia Minor, while Pacorus conquered the Levant. In Judaea Antigonus, the son of Aristobulus II, deposed his uncle John Hyrcanus II, captured a son of Antipater, Phasael (who committed suicide), and proclaimed himself the newest (and last) Maccabean ruler. He had Parthian assistance, but his victory was not complete, for another son of Antipater, Herod, escaped to Rome; there he so impressed Antony and Octavian that they named him king of the Jews, though he was an Idumaean.

In two years the Parthians had nearly restored the boundaries of the old Persian Empire. However, this success was even more quickly undone. Disagreement between the two generals weakened their combined effect. In 39 B.C. a Roman counterattack killed Labienus and recovered Asia Minor. One year later Pacorus got himself killed in Syria, when he attacked a Roman camp that he had been led to believe was undefended. Herod personally led another Roman army to retake Jerusalem, capturing the holy city after a five-month siege.

Before the year was up (37 B.C.), Orodes lost his mind and abdicated in favor of a savage son, Phraates IV, who then killed his father and some thirty brothers to secure the throne. The rest of his reign was so harsh that Mark Antony believed Parthia would be an easy conquest. In the spring of 36 B.C., he led 100,000 men into the Caucasus, Armenia and Atropatene. This army may have looked unstoppable, because it was larger than anything Phraates had on the scene, but Antony committed a major blunder by dividing his force, leaving part of it in the rear to guard the baggage and siege engines. These Phraates found and successfully attacked, destroying Antony's supplies and equipment. Harassed by the Parthian cavalry, unable to forage for supplies, unable to make a truce with his enemy, and facing a tough winter, Antony had no choice but to retreat. At that point, the king of Armenia switched sides, going over to the Parthians; this meant that the only escape route for the Romans went through enemy territory. It was a death march, with men dropping from hunger, disease, and Parthian arrows. 35,000 men--more than one third of the army--were lost in that retreat. Most humiliating of all, Antony retreated without fighting a single battle with the enemy, meaning those men had died in vain. Finally the surviving legions crossed the Euphrates into Syria, and the Parthian pursuers suddenly unstrung their bows, praised the Romans for their courage, and went home. Mark Antony headed for Egypt and the soothing attentions of Queen Cleopatra.

After this fiasco the Romans finally gave their eastern rivals the respect they deserved. Mark Antony prepared to fight the Parthians again by building a fleet of 400 ships, but the rematch never took place. Because the Parthian Empire did not control any land on the Mediterranean or Black Seas, those ships would have been useless anyway; Antony used them instead in his showdown with Octavian, the battle of Actium (31 A.D.). Then the Roman Republic became the Roman Empire, with Octavian, now known as Caesar Augustus, as its first emperor. The most embarrassing bit of unfinished business left to Augustus was his adoptive father's declared intention of marching against the Parthians. Augustus saw that Parthia defended itself well but had no power to sustain an offensive. Instead of starting another war, he was satisfied with reasserting Roman authority over Armenia and the Caucasus (20 B.C.); he also persuaded Phraates to return the standards captured at Carrhae. These moves restored Roman prestige and allowed Augustus to ignore the hawks who called for a radical solution to the Parthian problem. From now on the Euphrates River and the Arabian Desert became the official boundaries between the empires.

In the East, Augustus made his priority the Romanization of the areas already conquered. Fiefs that had been the reward of loyalty in more troubled times were turned into directly-ruled provinces, now that they had become peaceful and profitable: Rome absorbed Egypt in 30 B.C., Galatia in 25, Paphlagonia in 6, and Judaea in 6 A.D. Succeeding emperors continued the process: Tiberius annexed Cappadocia, Caligula took Mauretania (modern Morocco), Claudius took Thrace and Lycia (in SW Asia Minor), and Nero added Pontus. They divided Ituraea between the province of Syria and the Herodian kingdoms. Tiberius annexed Commagene (a small buffer state on the west bank of the Euphrates), but Caligula restored it and gave it part of Cilicia.

Herod the Great

The Temple stood in Jerusalem as an empty shell for a generation after Crassus looted it. In 20 B.C. Herod began to remodel and adorn it, so that it would compare favorably with the pagan temples the Greeks & Romans had built. This project took 46 years, to be completed shortly before Jesus started teaching in there. Herod also built palaces in out-of-the-way places to hide in when life in Jerusalem looked dangerous: the Herodium, located between Bethleham and Hebron, and Machaerus and Masada, both perched on high places overlooking the Dead Sea.

The second Temple, after Herod got done enlarging it.

Despite all he could do, Herod remained an unpopular king. His paranoia and personal cruelties outweighed his piety, and his Idumaean blood made him suspect anyway. Jews also distrusted Herod when they thought about the Temple. If King David could not build the first Temple because his hands were too bloody from military campaigns, then how clean could the hands of Herod be? When Herod set a golden eagle--the symbol of Imperial Rome--on the Temple gate, radical Jews called it proof that Herod served not God but Augustus, and tore it down at the cost of their own lives.

As he grew older, Herod grew more mentally unstable. Domestic troubles plagued him; even the crown prince, Antipater III, hated him. He murdered Mariamne, the favorite of his ten wives, her grandfather John Hyrcanus II, her brother Aristobulus, and several of his own children. The killing of the infants in Bethlehem when he heard of the birth of Jesus was only the last of many atrocities that he committed (Matt. 2:16).⁽¹⁾ When Augustus learned of these acts, he noted that Herod did not eat pork, in observance of Jewish law, and remarked: "It is better to be Herod's hog than to be his son!"

Although history calls him "Herod the Great," he knew that his death would bring rejoicing among the Jews. On his deathbed he actually ordered that all leaders of the Jews be executed at the time of his death so that there would be mourning throughout the land, if not for him. Happily, nobody carried out this murderous project (only Antipater III was killed), and there were few mourners when Herod died in 4 B.C.

The Tetrarchy

Augustus chose to compromise; he crowned Archelaus, but only gave him half his father's kingdom (Judaea, Samaria, and Idumaea). The rest of the kingdom was partitioned four ways, and they called the entire political framework the Tetrarchy, suggesting (incorrectly) that Israel was divided into four equal parts. The second surviving son of Herod, Herod Antipas, received Galilee and the east bank of the Jordan, or Peraea. A third son, Herod Philip, ruled the southwestern corner of Syria (Old Testament Bashan, today's Golan Heights). An apparently unrelated prince, Lysanias, ruled the fourth part of the tetrarchy, a small district called Abilene in eastern Lebanon; this area had not been part of Herod's kingdom. Salome got three cities: Azotus (ancient Ashdod), neighboring Jamnia, and Phasaelis (a town about 15 miles north of Jericho); upon her death they passed to Livia, the wife of Augustus, and eventually to Tiberius. Augustus effectively put Archelaus on probation, stating that if he ruled his lands well Rome would later make him king over Herod the Great's entire territory.

Still, Archelaus began at once to abuse his position, taking on more royal titles than a subservient ruler should have. He suppressed dissent brutally; for example, he killed three thousand Jews in the Temple during one Passover festival. In 6 A.D. Augustus banished Archelaus to Gaul; because the Romans had not yet conquered Britain, Gaul was as far from Israel as Augustus could exile him, without leaving the Empire. The territory of Archelaus now came under the direct rule of Coponius, the first procurator. In the sixty years between Archelaus and the Jewish-Roman War, no less than fourteen procurators tried to keep the lid on Judaea; the most famous is Pontius Pilate, who governed from 26 to 36 A.D.⁽²⁾

One verse in the New Testament mentions Archelaus, and it reflects his character perfectly. When the family of Jesus came back from their refuge in Egypt, Joseph did not take the direct road to Nazareth via Jerusalem; instead he chose a roundabout route to avoid the territories of Archelaus (Matt. 2:22).

Herod Antipas was sly, ambitious, and luxury-loving, but not an able ruler like his father. At first he was married to the daughter of Aretas, the Nabataean king. Later he intrigued with and eloped with Herodias, the wife of his half-brother Philip, although both of them were married at the time. This made for an incredibly tangled family tree, since Herodias was the granddaughter of Herod the Great, sister of the future Herod Agrippa I, and both niece and wife to Herod Philip. When John the Baptist denounced this scandal, Herod imprisoned and beheaded him (Matt. 14, Mark 6, and Luke 9).

Antipas was also aware of the ministry of Jesus. When he first heard about it, he wondered if John the Baptist had come back from the dead; Jesus replied by saying, "Go ye and tell that fox, behold I cast out devils" (Luke 13:32). When Jesus was put on trial in Jerusalem, Antipas had the Messiah sent to him, asked to see a miracle, and returned him to Pontius Pilate when he got no answer.

Herod Philip's territory was a non-Jewish area that he succeeded in Romanizing. He built a marble temple to Augustus above the older city of Panias, which he rebuilt under the name Caesarea Philippi. He enjoyed a peaceful reign of nearly thirty-eight years (4 B.C.-34 A.D.) and appears to have been the best of all the Herods.

Prelude to the New Testament

Though many Jews saw this period as an unhappy time to live in, Judaism did grow, in both numbers of followers and in diversity of sects. Estimates of the numbers of Jews living around 1 A.D. range from several hundred thousand to as many as five million. Whatever the figure was, more than half of them still lived in Iraq, as subjects of the Parthian Empire. In the west, they appear to have made up around one tenth of the Roman Empire's population. It takes more than just large families to explain how the Jewish community reached this size, and it probably came about by making converts (proselytes) from the surrounding Gentile population, especially during the Greek era covered in the previous chapter. Exact details are not available, though.

The two main Jewish sects of this time, the Pharisees and the Sadducees, split in the early second century B.C. Under Roman rule new groups, many with political goals, emerged in the Holy land. Most wanted an independent Jewish state, and all wanted a society where the Torah was observed properly. Many expected liberation under the leadership of the Messiah, who would come, pronounce the Last Judgment, resurrect the saints who had lived in the past, and turn Israel into God's invincible kingdom on earth. As a result this was a time when they wrote much apocalyptic literature, in the style of Old Testament prophets like Daniel.

One group of Jews who thought they were living in the last days were known as the Essenes. Members of this sect got away from Jerusalem and set up a hermit community at Qumran, on the shore of the Dead Sea, where they hoped to stay out of the major conflicts of the day while they prepared for the time to come. Here they owned everything in common, wore white robes instead of Greco-Roman fashions, and did their best to live virtuous lives, but they were not a true forerunner to the monastic movements that Christianity later produced; for one thing, they did allow marriage. Some scholars believe that John the Baptist may have been one of them.

The Essenes never numbered more than about 4,000, and they disappeared in the Jewish-Roman War when the Romans wiped out Qumran, on the road from Jerusalem to Masada. Before the mid-20th century, all we knew about them came from contemporary writers like Josephus, Philo, and Pliny the Elder. Then in 1947 we discovered the library of the Essenes, the famous Dead Sea scrolls, in a cave at Qumran. Written in Hebrew & Aramaic on parchment & papyrus, these texts are the oldest portions of the Bible ever found. Also found was the Manual of Discipline, a guide to the "children of light" on how to maintain righteousness in their struggle against the forces of darkness.

Contemporary with the Essenes were the Zealots, whose party was founded in 6 A.D. Unlike the Essenes, however, the Zealots got fully involved in Judaean politics. These first-century radicals refused to pay taxes to the Romans and advocated the violent overthrow of the regime, arguing that God was the only rightful master of Israel. If withholding tribute meant war, then they were fully prepared to wage it. Using tactics very similar to those of modern terrorists, they kidnaped or assassinated Roman officials and those Jews who got along with the Romans. Josephus, betraying his Roman bias, called them Sicarii (dagger men), because of their favorite weapon. Josephus and the Book of Acts both mention three Zealot-led revolts in the first century: Judas of Galilee (6 A.D.), Theudas (44), and Benjamin "the Egyptian" (60). The Romans stamped out these revolts and crucified the rebels with their famous efficiency. They may have seen the crucifixion of Jesus as the nipping of another rebellion in the bud.

A political group with more moderate views was called the Herodians. At first they apparently viewed Herod the Great as the Messiah. After Herod died, their objective became the establishment of an independent Israel with Herod's descendants ruling over it. Unlike the Zealots, however, they did not refuse to pay taxes to the Romans.

Finally mention should be made of Rabbi Hillel, the foremost Jewish scholar in the generation preceding Jesus. Born in Iraq, he came to Israel as a young man to pursue advanced studies of the Scriptures under the guidance of the Pharisees. No proper biography is available on Hillel's life and accomplishments; instead several legends have formed around what he said and taught. The most popular story tells how a young Greek came to Shammai, Hillel's chief rival, to mock the legalisms of Judaism; he dared someone to teach him the Torah while he stood on one foot. Shammai dismissed the fellow out of hand, but Hillel took up the challenge, summarizing the law as follows: "What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor. This is the whole Torah; the rest is commentary. Go and study." The Greek was so impressed that he converted.

Hillel's version of the golden rule echoes through his other teachings; in fact, his outlook on the Torah was that one could learn about man's relationship with God by examining his relationships with other people. His extensive searching of the Scriptures, to find out how they apply to daily life, mark him as the first of the rabbinical scholars whose writings would one day be compiled to form that collection of traditions and commentaries known as the Talmud.

The Birth of Christianity

or, A Long Time Ago, In a Galilee Far, Far Away . . .

The good news could not be kept a secret. On the contrary, the Apostles bubbled over with excitement and told anyone who would listen what had happened and was going to happen. Peter, for example, who had denied his master when the Romans arrested Jesus, now proclaimed him with the courage of a lion. Initially these early Christians stayed in and around Jerusalem, but when Herod Agrippa I and various Jewish leaders tried to stamp out the new movement, they moved their headquarters to Antioch in Syria, and the number of people who heard the Gospel grew exponentially.

At this point the early Church made a convert who would become the greatest missionary of all. This was Saul of Tarsus, a young Pharisee who had distinguished himself by his outstanding adherence to the Law and his persecution of the first Christians. Saul chased them from Jerusalem but was converted through a vision of the risen Christ on his way to Damascus. Temporarily blinded, he found his way to a Christian named Ananias, and when cured he began to preach the Gospel vigorously. Before long his former friends made plots against his life, and Saul had to escape Damascus by being lowered over the city wall in a basket. Saul wandered in Arabia for a while and then returned to Jerusalem, but here he faced a double problem: Christians who feared his conversion was not really genuine, and Jewish leaders who now viewed him as a traitor. He went home to Tarsus and lay low for about a decade, until the Church of Antioch called him back into the ministry. From this point on we call the rabbi from Tarsus by the Greek version of his name, Paul.

Using Antioch as his starting base, Paul now went on three epic missionary journeys through Asia Minor and Greece, which dominate the second half of the Book of Acts. Wherever he went, he first found the nearest synagogue to preach in, and when the Jewish congregation would not have him, he took his message to the Gentiles outside. Previously the Apostles had converted a handful of non-Jews (e.g., Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch, Peter and the Roman centurion Cornelius), but Paul was more dedicated to this ministry than anyone else; he even brought Peter back into line when Peter slipped into his old habits and associated only with Jewish Christians (Galatians 2:11-16). It was Paul who offered the Gentiles salvation without the necessity of following the 613 commandments of the Torah (plus all the rules the Pharisees & Sadducees had tacked on more recently). Being fluent in Greek, he was also able to express the message of Jesus in terms his Greek listeners could understand. Over time, Paul's activities caused a total change in Church demographics--by the end of the first century most of its members were non-Jewish, and would remain that way to this day.⁽³⁾

The area where Paul was active on his three missionary journeys. Not shown are Malta and Italy, where he went in the last two chapters of Acts.

The Journeys of the Apostles

1. The early Christians, except for Luke, the author of Acts, did not see a need to write a history of the Church. Most of them expected Jesus to come back within their own lifetimes, and they did not think they were creating an institution that would last for ages on this world.
2. Secular historians did not see Christianity as a significant movement--at first. Because Christianity's members came mostly from the poor/lower class elements of society, those with power and wealth ignored it for a long time. Only two non-Christian historians even bothered mentioning the name of Jesus in the first century: Josephus and Tacitus.
3. The Church did not research the stories of the Apostles until it was politically motivated to do so, in the fourth century. At this point the Church of Rome and the Eastern churches were starting to become rivals for the leadership of Christendom. Near the end of his career, the Roman Emperor Constantine the Great built the "Church of the Twelve Apostles" in Constantinople, to bury the relics (bones and other body parts) of all the Apostles inside. A search was made to find as many relics as possible; he successfully recovered most of the remains of Andrew, and those of Luke and Timothy (the latter two were not really Apostles, but close enough to use as substitutes). Rome held the bones of Peter and Paul and was not willing to part with them, so instead Constantine built a chapel over them in Rome that would one day become St. Peter's Cathedral. Then he died, and was buried in his unfinished church. Constantine's historian, Eusebius, claims that he really wanted to have his tomb surrounded by those of the Twelve, so that people would think of him as a thirteenth Apostle!

To fill the many existing gaps, we must rely on Church traditions/legends. Of course these are not the most reliable source of historical data, but where two or more separate accounts tell us the same thing (e.g., Peter died in Rome, Thomas went to India) we can guess that we are on safe ground. Also, remember that each Apostle had to go somewhere, so if only one country claims an Apostle as its missionary, he probably did go there. The rest of this section will act on those assumptions.

Simon Peter

Here the traditions take over. It is fairly certain that Peter visited Corinth shortly after Paul did, since he is mentioned in the two epistles to the Corinthians. Then he appears to have spent several years in Babylon (44-49 A.D.?); his first epistle is addressed from there. Some believe that when he said Babylon he meant Rome, as John did when he wrote the Book of Revelation, but this is unlikely, since Peter had no reason to disguise the name of Rome this early. There was a Christian community in Rome before 50 A.D. (the Emperor Claudius declared the Roman Christians a public nuisance and had them expelled--Acts 18:2), but it appears to have gotten started before any of the Apostles went there.

A few traditions suggest that Peter visited Gaul and even Britain, though these are unreliable. At the minimum he sent missionaries in that direction. Finally he ended up in Rome, and like Paul he became a martyr to Nero's persecution of the Christians. For nine months he was kept in the lower chamber of the notorious Mamertine dungeon; imagine being chained standing up against a wall in a cell so far underground that light never gets in, a place with a horrible stench because it had not been cleaned out in over a century. Despite all of this, Peter's faith remained unshaken, and he converted two of his jailers, along with 47 others. Then in 67 A.D. he was brought out and crucified in Nero's circus. He felt unworthy to die in the same manner of Jesus, and asked that he be crucified upside down. Ironically, the Romans granted this last request.

Andrew

Next Andrew crossed over into Europe via Byzantium. In Greece he converted a noblewoman, Maximilla, and she promptly became estranged from her husband, a proconsul named Aegeates. The enraged governor had the Apostle scourged and crucified, on an X-shaped piece of wood that we now call "St. Andrew's cross." The generally accepted date of Andrew's martyrdom is 69 A.D.

James the Son of Zebedee

Whether or not James made the long trip to Spain, it appears that most of his remains did in the seventh century. Then many bones identified as his turned up in Spain, but not his head; the story was that his skull was hidden somewhere in Jerusalem to keep it out of the hands of the Persians, who invaded the Holy Land in 614, while the rest of his relics were spirited away to more permanent safekeeping in Spain. Over those bones they built a shrine that grew into a cathedral, and then a city, named Santiago de Compostela. At the height of the Middle Ages, more pilgrims visited Compostela than any other site west of Rome. Even then there was some doubt about whether the bones of St. James were authentic, but the Catholic Church still accepts them as the real thing, since no rival claim exists elsewhere.

John

When Nerva became emperor in 96, he declared a general amnesty for all of Domitian's victims. John--now in his eighties or nineties--returned to Ephesus, and became the bishop in charge over all the churches in the province of Asia. He lived until the reign of the Emperor Trajan, around 100 A.D.

Philip

Bartholomew

Bartholomew teamed up with Philip at first, and the two went to Hierapolis in Phrygia. There they healed the wife of a Roman proconsul and she became a Christian; her husband ordered the crucifixion of both missionaries. They crucified Philip, but somehow Bartholomew escaped and went east to Armenia, around 60 A.D. He spent the next eight years near the Caspian Sea, before suffering martyrdom himself, in the city of Albanopolis (modern Derbend in Azerbaijan). Traditions disagree on whether he was flayed, beheaded, crucified, or suffered more than one of those fates.

Thomas

The traditions concerning Thomas are impressive indeed; they unanimously agree that he went east as far as India, and many historical facts back them up. According to the Church of the East (also known as the Nestorian, Assyrian, or Chaldean Church), he first went to Babylon, staying there long enough to found a congregation. When Peter arrived to take his place (44 A.D.) Thomas moved on. He went through Iran and into the Indus valley, where he converted a local king named Gondophares and his son Gad; coins have been found mentioning Suren kings by those names. A few years later the Tokhari came out of Central Asia, overran the Indus and founded the kingdom of Kushan, so Thomas traveled south to the Malabar coast, around 52 A.D. Here he converted many Hindu families, built seven churches, and crossed over to the east coast, where an unfriendly Brahman (Hindu priest) ended his career with a lance (60 A.D.).

Before it emigrated to Israel a few years ago, there was a Jewish community in south India at Cochin. A deed to the land their synagogue was built on dates to 72 A.D. Thomas very well could have witnessed to this group. In Mylapore, a suburb of Madras, are a very old house, chapel and tomb associated with him; at least they contain first-century style bricks.

Despite the missionary zeal of Thomas, his work, like anything made by man, was subject to change, decay, and corruption. During the next few centuries a Hindu revival erased every trace of the fledgling Christian community in northern India. The same fate might have befallen the south Indian believers, but news of their plight reached the Patriarch of Syria. In the fourth century he sent missionaries, led by one Thomas of Cana, to encourage them and let them know that they were not alone. After that various leaders in the Church of the East went there from time to time, and in the modern era Western clergymen have done the same thing. The Mar Thoma Church (St. Thomas Christians) still survives today, and claims a small but significant number of Christians in modern India.

Matthew

Traditions have him going in two directions after 44 A.D.; some send him to Persia, while others make him the missionary to Ethiopia. Of these, more writings back up the African case. He could have gone east first, but if he did so, he did not stay there for long; the traditional literature that covers his eastern trip comes from Europe, not Asia. He is credited with spending at least 23 years in Egypt and Ethiopia combined, witnessing before kings and dying in Egypt around the year 90. The stories of his death differ considerably; some say he was beheaded, while others claim a peaceful end. His body is now buried in Salerno, Italy, under an 11th-century cathedral, but nobody knows how or when it was found.

James the Son of Alphaeus

Now that we have taken care of that point, here is what we have on the two James. James the brother of Jesus was not a believer while Jesus was alive, but after the resurrection Jesus made a special appearance to prove to James that what he said was true (1 Cor. 15:5). Although not one of the Twelve, he became leader of the Church in Jerusalem, theoretically outranking the Twelve. He is mentioned as taking part in the conference concerning the acceptance of Gentile converts (Acts 15), and at some point wrote the epistle named after him. He was martyred around 53 A.D., when a mob led by the Sanhedrin threw him off the top of the Temple.

When the legends concerning James the brother of Jesus are attributed to the right person, there is little left for James the son of Alphaeus. The only tradition left that has a ring of probability comes from the Syrian Church. It states that when the Antioch church was founded, James the Less became its first leader. Years later he returned to Jerusalem and was stoned to death by the mob. His relics went to the Church of the Twelve Apostles in Constantinople during the mid-sixth century; in 572 they were moved to the Church of the Holy Apostles in Rome.

Thaddaeus

The Armenian church claims that five of the Apostles visited Armenia during their journeys, and that Thaddaeus was the first to arrive; Armenia's long relationship with Christianity started with the pioneering church he built in the city of Edessa, about 35 A.D. Then others (Bartholomew, Andrew, Simon, and Matthias) came to Armenia, and Thaddaeus moved on. After that he made some side excursions to the east, but he always came back to Armenia, using it as a home base. Wherever he went he seems to have been in the company of another Apostle; Thomas in Iraq, Bartholomew in Armenia, and Simon in Azerbaijan. He was finally martyred with a javelin or with arrows alongside Simon, and both were buried on the spot, in a small Iranian village named Kara Kelisa, about 40 miles from Tabriz.

An attractive legend concerning Thaddaeus has come to us from Eusebius. The story tells how Abgar, the king of Edessa, heard about Jesus and asked him to come to Edessa, to escape Jewish persecution and to heal him from poor health. In an Aramaic letter that Eusebius claimed to have seen, Jesus replied that he had to stay and fulfill the prophecies, but after his resurrection he would send one of his disciples to heal the king. Sure enough, a few years later Thaddaeus preached the gospel in Edessa and healed many sick people, including the king. The story ends with Thaddaeus refusing a large gift of gold and silver from the king. A variant of this story has Abgar's messenger choose to paint a picture of Jesus to satisfy the king's longing to see what he looks like. However, the face of Jesus glowed with so much radiance that no picture could be painted, so Jesus pulled a garment over his head. A permanent image of his face formed on the cloth, and many miracles were attributed to the garment after it went back to Abgar; presumably that was the first icon. If there is any truth to this whole story, then Thaddaeus became the first Christian to witness before a Gentile king.

Simon

The traditions concerning Simon the ex-terrorist have him almost circumnavigate the known world! First he went to Egypt, around 44 A.D. Next he worked his way along the North African coast, from Libya to Morocco, planting churches all the way. Boarding a ship, he went first to Gaul, then to Britain. A questionable English tradition has him traveling with Joseph of Arimathea at this point, and that Joseph left in Britain the cup used in the Last Supper; that inspired the famous quest for the Holy Grail.

When Simon arrived in Britain he was not able to stay long, for it was 60 A.D., and the island was engulfed in the revolt led by the British queen, Boadicea, against the Roman forces. The burning of London forced him to go back to the Continent; then he returned to Israel. On his next journey he wandered north and east, through Syria, Armenia, and Iraq. Finally he joined Thaddaeus in northern Iran, and the two were martyred together there.

Matthias

Matthias probably was one of the "seventy" sent out by Jesus in Luke 10:1. Only a few traditions exist concerning his later ministry, but they point to a path almost identical to the one taken by Andrew. First he made a beeline to Armenia, becoming yet another Apostle to witness there. Then he went to Colchis, and followed the Black Sea coastline as far as Sevastopol in the Crimea. Possibly Andrew accompanied him at this point; one wild story has Matthias captured by a tribe of cannibals, until Andrew came and rescued him. Then he returned to Jerusalem, battered from his experiences, to find a hostile reception waiting for him. The date of his final martyrdom varies from 51 to 64 A.D. His relics, like many others, were later found and moved to Europe by the zealous St. Helena, and have been enshrined in Triers, Germany, since 1127.

The Last Herods

Herod Agrippa I, born in 10 B.C., was the son of Bernice and Aristobulus, who was slain by his father, Herod the Great. His parents were first cousins, and if that didn't make the family tree complicated enough, he married another cousin, who was the daughter of an aunt, who again was married to an uncle! Josephus called him "Agrippa the Great," and praised him for defending Judaism, while the 12th chapter of Acts portrays him as a persecutor of the early Church. He appears to have been a kindly and likeable, if vain fellow; all of our sources credit him with extraordinary skill in oratory. In religion he followed the letter of the law but not the spirit of it, attentive to "tithe of mint and anise and cumin," while neglecting "the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith."

Agrippa got the Herodian throne because he got along well with a future Roman emperor, Gaius Caligula. One day the two of them were riding together in a chariot, and Agrippa confided that he wished Emperor Tiberius would hurry up and die, so that the government would pass to Caligula. The charioteer, one Eutychus, reported the remark to Tiberius, and Agrippa was thrown in prison. The story goes that he was in the palace courtyard, waiting to be locked up with some other victims of the paranoid emperor, and there happened to be an owl sitting in the tree he was leaning against. A German prisoner noticed this, asked a soldier who that man in purple was, and learned that he was a leader of the Jewish nation. The German then told Agrippa that the owl is a bird of omens, and predicted that its presence here was a sign that Agrippa would soon be released, but beware--because the next time he saw an owl, he would only have five days left to live.

True to the prophecy, Agrippa's humiliation was brief; six months later Tiberius died and Caligula became emperor. As soon as Agrippa had time to shave and put on a respectable garment, Caligula summoned him to the palace, gave him a crown, and had his iron chain replaced with a gold one of equal weight. Caligula also gave him the former tetrarchy of his uncle, Herod Philip. Agrippa hung the golden chain in the Temple as a memorial to what he had suffered, and a lesson in how God can suddenly raise up the fallen.

Most Jews were pleased to see Agrippa come back as a king, but not his uncle, Herod Antipas. While Tiberius was emperor Antipas had intrigued with Sejanus, a Roman officer who coveted the throne, and with the Parthians; he also stored away enough armor to outfit 70,000 men, in case a Roman-Parthian war involved Judaea. In 39 Caligula called Antipas to judgment. He went willingly, because he never got along well with Agrippa, was extremely jealous of him, and wanted the emperor to grant him all the lands once owned by Herod the Great. Agrippa also acted, sending his freedman Fortunatus to Rome with documents proving the accusations against Antipas. Antipas was just having his first interview when Fortunatus arrived and presented the letters to the emperor. The tetrarch could not deny the charges, so he confessed his guilt. Caligula removed him from office, banishing him to Gaul for the rest of his life; the tetrarchy of Antipas was handed over to Agrippa.

Not long after this, Caligula decreed that every man should worship him as a god. Petronius, the prefect of Syria, was ordered to place a gilded statue of the emperor in the Jerusalem Temple. An embassy of Jews, led by the author Philo, tried to talk Caligula out of it, but when the emperor saw them, he said "Begone!" Ten thousand Jews met Petronius in Acre and pleaded with him not to "violate the laws of their forefathers," but if he persisted in carrying out his mission, he would have to kill them first. Petronius was impressed with their loyalty to their faith, and announced he would wait while he sent a letter to Rome explaining the Jewish point of view. Agrippa, who was in Rome then, gave Caligula a magnificent banquet, and drank to his health until the emperor, full of wine, generously offered to grant any request that might contribute to Agrippa's happiness. Instead of taking anything for himself, he said, "This is my petition, that thou wilt no longer think of the dedication of that statue which thou hast ordered to be set up in the Jewish Temple by Petronius." Caligula rescinded the order, but because Petronius had delayed in carrying out the emperor's previous orders, he was ordered to commit suicide. Fortunately for Petronius, he did not get the order until after Caligula was assassinated, so when the order arrived, it no longer mattered.

The new emperor, Claudius, was also a friend of Agrippa. In the year he came to power (41) he enlarged Agrippa's domain by giving him Abilene, Judaea, and Samaria; except for Idumaea, all of Herod the Great's realm was under his control. Now at the height of his career, he began building new walls to fortify Jerusalem, but Marsus Vibius, the new prefect of Syria, ordered the construction stopped merely because it made him suspicious. Then Agrippa invited five petty kings like himself to attend a royal festival in the city of Tiberias. Marsus Vibius also came; Agrippa and the other vassal kings met him in chariots about a mile from the city, to do him honor. Yet Marsus, true to his character, thought that a meeting of monarchs would cause trouble for the Romans, and ordered everyone to leave at once.

It was after this that Herod Agrippa tried to stamp out the Church. He started arresting Christian leaders, beheaded James the brother of John, and would have done the same to Peter. However, the intervention of an angel delivered Peter from prison one night. Presumably Herod was trying to win favor with the Jewish leaders; he always thought he had to prove he was worthy of their support, because of his Idumaean roots.

One day in 44 A.D. Agrippa gave a festival at Caesarea; games were held and prayers were said for the safety and health of Emperor Claudius. The second day began when Agrippa entered the theater wearing "a garment made wholly of silver and of a texture truly wonderful." When the sun shone on this outfit it made him look radiant. The people proclaimed him a god, and he did nothing to stop their flattery. Then he looked up, saw an owl perched on a rope above his head, and remembered the second part of the German prisoner's prediction. He immediately began suffering severe pains, and died five days later. He left behind as heirs three daughters (Bernice, Mariamne, and Drusilla) and a son, 17-year-old Herod Agrippa II.

At this time Herod Agrippa II was in Rome, receiving an imperial education. Claudius decided that Agrippa was too young to receive his father's throne, and that the kingdom was too big to trust to someone whose loyalty had not yet been tested. So they partitioned Israel again: Agrippa got the lands north and east of the Jordan River, the former tetrarchies of Lysanias & Herod Philip, while the rest of the territory went back under direct Roman rule. In 53 Agrippa returned home and took charge of his ministate. Some time after this he appeared in Acts 26, and Paul made a defense of Christianity before him that many regard as one of the best speeches in the New Testament.

Herod Agrippa II, unlike his father, was never popular with his subjects. Presumably this is because his Roman connections were too obvious. Because of this he ultimately failed in what the Romans considered his most important task--keeping the people quiet. Yet in his favor we must argue that the Romans did nothing to make his job easier. The next Roman emperor, Nero, took his cult of personality seriously and insisted upon worship from all of his subjects, Jews included. This was idolatry pure and simple, and thus repugnant to any Jew. Finally there was the character of the last procurator, Gessius Florus. He was a real money-grubber, who treated the Jews with such heavy-handedness that it seems like he wanted a revolt from them. In 66 a major riot broke out between the Jews and Greeks of Caesarea, and Florus demanded a heavy fine from the Temple treasury to cover damages. Refused, he came to Jerusalem, met with a large Jewish delegation that opposed his looting, grew angry, and ended the meeting by ordering the slaying of some 3,600 Jews. In desperation the Jews turned to Agrippa and to the high priests, and asked permission to send ambassadors to argue their case against Florus before Nero. Agrippa responded with a tear-filled speech, where he pleaded that the Jews desist from acts of violence, and greatly moved the people who heard it. Still, it was not enough to stop the ticking bomb. Nor could it be stopped by the threat of reprisal from the Roman legions, or even by the actions of cooler heads within the Sanhedrin--moderate Pharisees and the pro-Roman Sadducees. When Agrippa saw that war was inevitable, he joined the Romans and made war against his abused and aggrieved subjects, though it meant the destruction of his own kingdom.

The Jewish-Roman War

When the Romans lost 6,000 men, along with their baggage and siege engines, Nero made his best general, Vespasian, governor of Judaea. Beginning in Galilee, he besieged the fortress of Jotapata, near modern Haifa. Josephus resisted for 47 days, then escaped with forty men to a nearby cave. Each fugitive made a pledge to die by the hand of a comrade rather than let himself be captured by the Romans. Josephus arranged to be one of the last two survivors, then surrendered to the enemy, became a friend and advisor to Vespasian, and was eventually rewarded with Roman citizenship. After the war he wrote his famous history books, The Antiquities of the Jews and The Wars of the Jews. These works are invaluable in understanding the background of the New Testament, but Josephus wrote them to justify the actions of the Romans, and his own questionable behavior. Despite his efforts, Jews still regard him as a traitor today.

The Jews got a reprieve when Nero died in 68 A.D. In the chaos of the following year, three generals rose and fell from the throne. Vespasian stayed out of the civil war at first, until he realized that any general with enough force to back him up could claim the purple for himself. Soon he was making plans with a former rival, Gaius Licinius Mucianus, the governor of Syria, and the two of them secretly enlisted the support of Egypt's governor, Tiberius Julius Alexander. Neither Alexander nor Mucianus was imperial material, the former because he was a renegade Jew, the latter because he had no sons and thus could not form a dynasty. Vespasian on the other hand had two sons, Titus and Domitian, so the governors agreed to back him. Before long the legions in Asia Minor, Armenia, and Egypt went over to their side. Vespasian chose to stay in the east, where he could keep an eye on Judaea; Alexander cut off Egypt's grain supply, which was vital to Rome; Mucianus invaded Italy by way of the Danube. By the end of the year the Empire was theirs. Vespasian went to Rome to claim his prize, leaving his son Titus behind to finish the job of putting down the Jewish rebellion.

In March of 70 A.D., four Roman legions and their auxiliaries--a total of about 80,000 men, arrayed themselves outside the walls of Jerusalem, a city with perhaps 25,000 defenders inside. Unfortunately for the Zealots, they were divided into moderate and extremist factions, and fought for leadership of the rebellion until the siege began. When that happened, though, they resisted fanatically, knowing there was no hope if they surrendered (every day Titus crucified Jewish prisoners, sometimes as many as 500, in sight of the defenders). As fast as the catapults, battering rams, and siege towers could be brought up, the defenders destroyed them, but the Romans repaired them with a minimum of delay. This stalemate went on for fifteen days, until the Romans breached the outer walls. After that the battle continued, fought with even more savagery than before. Old men and women joined in defending against the Romans, dropping stones and boiling oil on those trying to scale the walls. Even the stones the Romans catapulted into the city were flung back at them. All this delayed the attackers, but it did not stop them; they continued to advance, yard by yard. Meanwhile famine gripped the city, killing many more defenders. The fortress of Antonia, which overlooked the Temple, fell in late July. In August--the Hebrew date is the 9th of Av, the same date on which Solomon's Temple had been destroyed six and a half centuries earlier--the second Temple went up in flames. Resistance continued in the upper part of the city for one more month before the siege finally ended.⁽⁴⁾

Like Nebuchadnezzar had done, Titus reduced Jerusalem to rubble and led the survivors into exile and slavery. The struggle had been so tough that Titus memorialized it in a famous arch that shows the Romans parading with the seven-branched menorah, trumpets, tables, and other loot from the Temple. They stamped coins that showed Titus standing in a pose of triumph under the words IUDAEA CAPTA (Judaea is captive). Of the estimated 97,000 prisoners that they took to Rome, 17,000 died on the way; in one ghastly spectacle, done to celebrate the birthday of prince Domitian, 2,500 Jewish youths were killed in a single day, fighting wild animals or each other in gladiatorial games. The Sanhedrin and the Temple priesthood were abolished, and in a move the Jews found especially galling, the half-shekel tax they had once paid to support the Temple now went to the support of pagan cults, like that of the Roman god Jupiter.

John of Gischala and Simon bar Giorah both survived the siege of Jerusalem, and were among the prisoners taken to Rome. After being exhibited in Titus' triumph, Simon suffered the usual fate of defeated kings; he was put to death at Rome's greatest temple to Jupiter, on the Capitoline Hill. The date and manner of John's death is unknown to us.

The Herodian royal family chose to retire in Italy. Agrippa moved to Rome, received the honorary rank of praetor, and lived until the year 100 A.D. One of his sisters, Drusilla, was killed in 79 A.D., by the famous eruption of Mt. Vesuvius that buried Pompeii.

There were a few Zealots holding out in Herod the Great's hideaway palaces that had to be dealt with before Rome could declare the war finished. The Herodium was captured quickly, while Machaerus, where John the Baptist had been killed, did not fall until its leader was captured in 71. Masada was the hardest nut to crack, perched atop a mesa a quarter mile above the shore of the Dead Sea. For three years nearly 1,000 men, women, and children held it against 15,000 Romans in eight surrounding camps. It took the construction of a huge earthen ramp up the slope of the mountain before they could breach the walls of Masada. When that happened in 73, the Romans found only two women and five children left alive inside the fortress; the rest had committed suicide, choosing death before dishonor. To modern Israelis Masada is an example of heroism against hopeless odds, remembered by them in much the same way that Texans remember the Alamo. Today's Israeli soldiers take their oath of allegiance there, swearing that "Masada will not fall again."

Parthia: The Anti-Hellenistic Period

At the beginning of this period the Roman Emperor Augustus and his Parthian counterpart, Phraates IV, were about as friendly as two rivals can get. Together they reached an agreement concerning Palmyra, an oasis in the east Syrian desert that had become vital to the commerce of both powers; Rome nominated a Hellenized vassal to rule it, and Phraates accepted, though Parthian public opinion didn't. Then Augustus sent a slave girl named Musa to the harem of Phraates. The wily concubine gave birth to a son, and persuaded Phraates that it would be a good idea to send the king's older sons to Rome for safekeeping; he did, thinking it was good for international relations. After the other princes were gone, she poisoned the king, had her son crowned, and married him. Thus in a few years Musa rose from royal gift to queen.

Their joint reign lasted from 2 B.C. to 6 A.D. (five years, because there is no "year zero," remember), and then Musa and her husband/son, Phraates V, were driven from the throne. Now the other princes came home from abroad. Two of them, Orodes III & Vonones, were the next kings of the realm. Both of them were short-lived, and noted for their weakness and pro-Roman sympathies; Vonones, to the disgust of his subjects, was not even interested in horses!

In 12 A.D. the barons ousted Vonones and replaced him with a ruler more to their liking. That was Artabanus III (12-38), the son of the viceroy of Hyrcania, who had royal blood on his mother's side. As it turned out, Artabanus was not an easy instrument for others to manipulate. Violently anti-Roman in character, he eagerly wanted to drive the Romans out of Asia. His attempt to place a son on the throne of Armenia failed, though, and after that he devoted the rest of his reign to internal reforms. He did this by humbling the nobles, taking away many of their hereditary privileges, and removing unreliable barons. Several satellite states in the west--Charax, Elymais, Persis, and Atropatene--received members of the Parthian royal family as rulers. The great city of Seleucia on the Tigris, however, revolted, and it took seven years to regain control there; in the east the Suren king Gondophares declared himself independent (19) and took the title "King of Kings."

The next important king was a real Iranian nationalist, Vologaeses I (51-78). Under him a genealogy was invented that purported to show the Achaemenid ancestry of the Arsacid house. The reverse side of his coins showed a Zoroastrian priest at a fire-altar, and bore letters in Pahlavi (Parthian), instead of Greek script. According to tradition the Zoroastrian holy book, the Zend Avesta, was compiled during his reign. To cut Seleucia down to size, he built a rival city named Vologasia, which soon became a commercial center in his own right.

It was not only Greek culture that withered away at this time; the ancient Mesopotamian civilization, which occupied center stage in the first four chapters of this work, had been dying slowly ever since Cyrus the Great captured Babylon. Part of this was because civilization had spread far beyond the Fertile Crescent; Iraq was no longer the busiest place in the civilized world. The Persian Royal Road, for example, passed north of Babylonia instead of through it. The Persian kings did what they could to maintain the cities, but events elsewhere, like the struggle with Greece, occupied most of their attention. Gradually, buildings crumbled, canals silted up and farms turned into deserts.

As the economy deteriorated and the local hydrographics changed, people moved away. Then other people moved in, but they were not Semites; they spoke Persian, Aramaic or Greek as their first language. To them, the cuneiform inscriptions on clay tablets were meaningless, and a nation which forgets its language loses both its past and its identity. During the Greek era cuneiform disappeared from everyday use, until only scholars and temple scribes could understand it. The last existing cuneiform text, an astronomical almanac, was written in 74 or 75 A.D. When the Roman emperor Trajan visited Babylon in 115 A.D., he did not "take the hand of Marduk," as Babylonian kings had done, but sacrificed to the spirit of Alexander the Great. In 199, Septimius Severus found the city completely deserted.

Vologaeses wanted one of his brothers, Tiridates, to become king of Armenia, but Rome opposed this move with force. The result was an inconclusive ten-year war, which ended in 66 with a compromise: Armenia could have a Parthian monarch if he submited to Roman authority. Tiridates went to Rome with his family and 3,000 nobles, and there he received his new crown from Nero. The Parthian dynasty would survive in Armenia long after it disappeared from Parthia itself, until 428.

While all these events were happening, the Parthian state began disintegrating into several smaller countries. The chronic weakness of the central government brought this on. In fact, from the Roman point of view Parthia was not one kingdom but a confederation of eighteen. In 58 Hyrcania became independent. On the eastern frontier a powerful central Asian state, Kushan, arose between Parthia and China; now somebody else could play the same middleman game that the Parthians had played with the Romans and the Chinese. In the west Rome resumed the process of absorbing vassal states that had begun a century earlier; Vespasian annexed Emesa and Commagene.

In 78 Pacorus II came to the throne, only to be thrown out a year later by Artabanus IV, who likewise lasted a year before Pacorus II returned to depose him. Pacorus now kept the throne, but not much more. Barons refused to obey the crown, and they had more control over the army and finances than the king did. Plots hatched, and Rome sometimes got involved in them to advance Roman interests. In 109 Pacorus was replaced by Osrhoes, his brother or brother-in-law.

The borders Augustus gave the Roman Empire changed little until Trajan came to the throne. An impartial administrator and a talented general, he conquered Dacia (Romania) in 106. Then he moved east, turning the Nabataean kingdom into the Roman province of Arabia (also 106). In 113 he got an excuse to attack the Parthians when they replaced the king of Armenia without Rome's consent. Trajan began his campaign in the following year, taking Edessa and Armenia with little resistance. The Armenian king put his crown at Trajan's feet, but was deposed anyway. In 115 the emperor advanced into Iraq. Adiabene, the nearest Parthian client state, became the new province of Assyria; Ctesiphon fell to the legions and Trajan carried off a daughter of Osrhoes and the Parthian throne; the Romans continued down the Tigris until they captured Charax. Before the year was up Trajan stood on the shore of the Persian Gulf, thinking aloud of Alexander. But the Iranian response was not late in coming. The loss of Ctesiphon persuaded the formerly divided princes to unite against the invader. The new provinces revolted, and the Parthians invaded Armenia and Assyria. Trajan responded by returning to Ctesiphon and crowning a vassal king there, but this attempt to disunite the Parthian chiefs failed. After he failed to take Hatra, a fortress in the northern Iraqi desert, Trajan declared the campaign over and died on his way home.

Again Parthia had thrown back a superior enemy. The next emperor, Hadrian, decided that Augustus had the right idea and promptly pulled back to the Euphrates. He returned the golden throne and the royal princess, Armenia returned to its previous role as a client kingdom, and only Edessa remained as a souvenir from Rome's easternmost expedition. When Osrhoes struggled with his successor, Vologaeses III, Hadrian stayed out of it. He even invited Osrhoes to visit Rome. The peace between them was a genuine one, lasting for more than 40 years.

Bar Kochba's Revolt

Although the Jews were grief-stricken by the loss of their temple and their state, they could not accept defeat. In 116, while Trajan was campaigning against the Parthians, a Libyan Jew named Lukuas or Andreas was proclaimed as the Messiah. Zealot-influenced revolts flared up in Cyrenaica (eastern Libya), Cyprus, Egypt, Asia Minor, Judaea, and Iraq. They were an embarrassment to the Romans, but by 117 they had crushed them all. Still, significant damage had been done to the Empire. For a start, the revolts played a part in the decision of Hadrian to abandon most of the conquests of Trajan; the rebels were a potential threat to the emperor and his legions in the east. The revolt in Egypt was so bad that the governor had to flee from Alexandria until reinforcements arrived, while Cyrenaica was so depopulated that Hadrian eventually authorized a new settlement program for that province. In the case of Cyprus, Hadrian made sure it would stay peaceful afterwards by decreeing that no Jews would be allowed to move there.

The biggest casualty of these revolts was the Jewish community of Alexandria, which had produced the Septuagint and Philo. The extinguishing of this community also brought an end to the movement to Hellenize Judaism. Ironically, since Hadrian admired everything Greek, he probably would have supported the Hellenized Jews, had he understood the Jewish factions. From now on Judaism was dominated by its Pharisaic faction, which is probably just as well; had the Sadducees or some other group survived instead, Judaism might not be recognizable today.

The mopping-up of the Jewish revolts continued into Hadrian's reign. In 130, while touring the Empire, Hadrian visited Judea. Sixty years after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem, the Jewish capital was still in ruins; the city's only inhabitants were a few Jews living in hovels. Still not showing any understanding of Judaism, or of monotheism in general, Hadrian decided that if the Jews became pagans, they wouldn't be unhappy people anymore. For that reason he imitated the actions of Antiochus Epiphanes, by announcing that he would build a temple to Jupiter on the site of the former Jewish Temple. Coupled with this affront were prohibitions on circumcision, observing the Sabbath, and public instruction in the Torah. It was the worst decision Hadrian ever made, all the more amazing when one considers that he ruled wisely in other matters. Nothing was more likely to goad the Jews into rebellion.

The leader of the revolt, Simeon bar Kosiba, was hailed as the Messiah by the greatest rabbi of the time, Akiba ben Joseph. Simeon was called "Bar Kochba" ("Son of a Star") by his admirers, and "Bar Koziba" ("Son of a Liar") by detractors. According to the Talmud, he was an extremely charismatic leader, who required that his soldiers cut off one of their fingers to prove their loyalty and valor, until the sages pleaded, "How long will you continue to turn all Israel into maimed men?" For two years he planned strategies and stockpiled weapons and supplies; Akiba traveled in the Diaspora, to places as far away as Gaul and Iraq, gathering support from the Jews living there. When the rebellion began, in early 132, the Roman Tenth Legion, caught by surprise, had to abandon Jerusalem. Bar Kochba established a provisional government, planned to rebuild the Temple, and set up a temporary altar for sacrifices on the Temple site. They proclaimed a new calendar and minted new coins, both calling 132 A.D. "Year One of the Redemption of Israel." Bar Kochba was so confident that he once prayed before a battle: "O Lord, do not help the enemy; as for us, we need no help."

Moderate Pharisees, pacifists, and pro-Roman sympathizers argued against the war, but the patriotic roar of the people drowned their voices. Meanwhile, Hadrian called for reinforcements, and brought his best general, Sextus Julius Severus, from Britain to lead them. Using the same strategy that had worked in the last war, Severus chose to surround the Jewish strongholds and starve them into submission. In early 135, he finally managed to drive the rebels from Jerusalem. Bar Kochba and his men dug in at the fortress of Betar, seven miles away, but by late summer that had also been taken. Bar Kochba died in the final battle, Rabbi Akiba was imprisoned and tortured to death, and the rebellion was over.

After the war Hadrian finished off Judaea. Jerusalem was utterly destroyed, and a blatantly pagan city, Aelia Capitolina, took its place, with a temple to Jupiter where the Jewish Temple had once stood. A Gentile population moved in to settle the city, and Jews were only allowed in once a year, to visit the last remnant of the old Temple (the Wailing Wall) and grieve for what they had lost. An estimated 500,000 Jews were killed either during the rebellion or in its aftermath, and thousands more were enslaved. Rome even changed the name of the Holy Land, to Syria Palestina (Philistine Syria), a name that dredged up memories of Israel's ancient archenemy. That, by the way, is where we get the modern term Palestine; it was an act of anti-Semitism by the Romans.

One of the most famous lines in the works of Tacitus is "They make a desert and call it peace." This quote supposedly came from a British chieftain, who described in 84 A.D. how the Romans pacified his country after they conquered it, but it is even a better description of what the Romans did to the Holy Land. The Jews responded by giving Hadrian a special curse. Since 135, whenever a Jew mentioned Hadrian's name, he was likely to add the line "may his bones be crushed." No other Roman, not even Titus, the destroyer of the second Jewish Temple, has received this honor.

The fall of Betar marks the end of an era in Jewish history. Temple worship and ritual sacrifice could no longer be practiced. The Jews no longer had any real hope of reclaiming Jerusalem. There would be no more Jewish revolts. For most of the next 1,800 years the Jews would be a despised minority just about everywhere they lived, even in Israel itself. Politics had been burned out of Judaism, not to return until the Zionist movement got started in the 19th century. Meanwhile the Jews turned their energies to spiritual and literary pursuits; the result was the creation of the Talmud in the 2nd-6th centuries. The Romans responded by gradually releasing their iron grip upon the Jewish people, turning their attention to the Christians instead.⁽⁵⁾

Commerce Under the Pax Romana

The Indian trade started early in the bronze age, with a direct connection by sea between western India and the Persian Gulf. It suffered a partial interruption when the Indus Valley civilization fell around 1500 B.C., and recovered sometime between 1000 and 500 B.C. After that it gradually increased in importance, as unnamed explorers blazed trails across the ocean east to Southeast Asia, and west to the Red Sea. Late in the second century B.C. India and China started trading; the Indian traders traveled northwest until they reached Balkh in Afghanistan, the nearest stop on the Silk Road, before turning northeast toward China. Besides trade goods, China got Buddhism, which Indian missionaries brought (with the help of Parthian and Kushan converts).

While the silk trade was getting started, the Greeks of Alexandria learned that the currents and winds of the Indian Ocean change with the seasons; once they learned the best times to sail in each direction, they could join Indian merchants on that body of water. At the Egyptian end of the journey they built roads and ports and refurbished the Nile-Red Sea canal. That was a wasted effort, because the winds at the northern end of the Red Sea are unreliable and merchants preferred to unload their cargo halfway up the coast, carry it across the desert to the Nile, and sail downstream the rest of the way. Indeed, Pharaoh's trading expeditions were doing the same thing before 2000 B.C.

The trading network between the Roman, Parthian, Kushan and Chinese empires, showing the land (red) and sea (blue) routes.

The Romans were always worrying over the gold they spent on their foreign trade, but they probably earned enough from the manufactured goods exported to cover the cost of imports. Besides, in India gold was scarce and what the Indians got was overvalued by Mediterranean standards. The number of classical style works of art found in Central Asia suggests a wide demand for Roman goods, and in glassware the cities of the Levant had no rivals.⁽⁶⁾ In brief, the archeological evidence suggests that Rome's balance of trade was healthy, and we should not take moralistic pronouncements on the gold drain and foreign luxuries very seriously.

The Two Empires in Trouble

Rome had two co-emperors at this point, Marcus Aurelius and Lucius Verus. You will recognize Marcus Aurelius if you have read Meditations, the philosophy book he wrote in his spare time, or if you have seen the movie "Gladiator." Lucius Verus, on the other hand, wasn't a soldier or a philosopher; he wanted to enjoy the luxuries that go to the top man, but didn't want the responsibilities. When Marcus put Lucius in charge of the reinforcements that came from Europe, Lucius took nine months to advance from Rome to Antioch. Part of the reason for his slow trip was because he suffered from an illness on the way, but he also acted like a tourist, making a lengthy stop at every place that offered entertainment or attractions worth seeing. Then in Antioch he met a young woman named Panthea who was both beautiful and educated; he found her more interesting and stayed in Syria. While Lucius dallied with his new mistress, it fell upon his generals, especially one Gaius Avidius Cassius, to win the war. Fortunately the generals were competent enough to act without their emperor. Retracing the steps of Trajan, they recovered Armenia in 163; in 165 Ctesiphon was captured a second time, and the royal palace was burned.

An unexpected and dangerous ally saved the Parthians. The Romans contracted a strange and hideous disease, probably smallpox, while marching through Atropatene. The resulting epidemic forced them to retreat, though they managed to inflict heavy losses on the pursuing Parthians. The Romans brought the disease home with them, and during the next few years, the Great Pestilence, as they called it, killed as many as one quarter of the residents in some Roman cities and started the Empire on its long decline.

The first step in that decline was an unsuccessful revolt by G. Avidius Cassius. Marcus Aurelius was ill in early 175, and a false report announced his death. Cassius had been a loyal general previously, and after the Parthian war he was appointed governor of Syria. Suddenly, before anyone could check to find out if the rumor was true, the soldiers around Cassius hailed him as the next emperor. He went along with this because Commodus, the son of Marcus Aurelius, was too young to rule; soon Egypt and all but two Asian provinces (Bithynia and Cappadocia) joined the rebellion. But then news arrived that Marcus was still alive, had returned to Rome from the Danube, and was now marching east. It was too late to back down and say "I'm sorry," so Avidius Cassius tried to continue his pursuit of the throne, but his followers began to fall away, and three months after the rebellion started, Cassius was stabbed by a centurion who thought he had no chance of winning. Then Marcus arrived on the scene; he lamented that he never got a chance to meet his opponent, refused the dead general's head when it was offered to him, and ordered that it be buried instead. Five years later, in 180, Marcus died; when his reign ended, so did the Pax Romana.

The assassinations of the next two emperors, Commodus and Pertinax, left the Empire up for grabs. While the Praetorian guards auctioned the realm to the highest bidder, three governors in the provinces made bids for the throne. One of them was Syria's governor, Pescennius Niger. When he proclaimed himself a candidate in 193, the nine legions of Asia and Egypt immediately proclaimed their support; the new king of Parthia, Vologaeses V (191-207), also offered to help, though problems at home kept him from sending more than a few troops from his client-princes. Then Niger crossed the Bosporus and took the nearest European city, Byzantium. That was as far as he could go, because one of his rivals, Septimius Severus, made it to Rome first. Severus marched east, put Byzantium under siege, and defeated Niger in battles at Cyzicus, Nicaea, and Issus. Niger was caught and slain while trying to flee across the Euphrates (195). His head was brought to Severus, who in turn sent it to Byzantium as warning against further resistance. Sure enough, when the city finally fell at the end of 197, Severus ruthlessly carried out the threatened reprisals.

Since Vologaeses had supported his enemy, Severus felt a need to teach the Parthians a lesson before he went home. At this point Vologaeses was besieging Nisibis, an Armenian-ruled city in northern Iraq. Marching directly across the Euphrates, Severus captured Seleucia and sacked Ctesiphon for the third time (197). However, the Parthians destroyed the surrounding countryside in a scorched-earth policy. Faced with starvation if he stayed, Severus relinquished the capital, tried without success to take Hatra, and retired to Syria.⁽⁷⁾ He did, however, gain some territory; Nisibis became the capital of Rome's easternmost province.

After Septimius Severus Rome passed through a series of increasingly alarming emperors. Severus' brutal son, Caracalla, declared war on Parthia in 214. He did it because he was obsessed with Alexander the Great, and wanted to repeat Alexander's eastern conquests. For the first campaign he removed the king of Edessa, but failed to conquer Armenia. Next he went to Alexandria to pay his respects at Alexander's tomb, and massacred the city's population when he heard they were making jokes about him. According to the historian Herodian, when Caracalla returned to the frontier, he invited the Parthian king, Artabanus V, to a summit meeting, where they would talk about peace and a possible marriage between the emperor and a daughter of Artabanus. The Parthian entourage showed up and set aside their weapons to show their good intentions, and Caracalla treacherously ordered his troops to kill them; Artabanus got away, but most of his retinue were slain, including the princess Caracalla was supposed to marry.

With the war resumed, Caracalla crossed the Tigris, ravaged Media, and added some more Iraqi real estate to the Empire, before his bad behavior caught up with him. At this point, Macrinus, one of Caracalla's joint Praetorian prefects, took fright, because he saw his name mentioned as a security risk in the emperor's private correspondence, meaning that his life was in danger. He got a chance to strike first when Caracalla left Edessa with a few bodyguards to visit the temple of the moon-god at Carrhae, twenty-five miles away. I believe this is the same temple as the ancient E.HUL.HUL, the place where Abraham's father Terah worshiped his gods (see Chapter 1), and the temple the Babylonian king Nabonidus wanted to recover from the Medes (see Chapter 4). Anyway, the guards brought back Caracalla's dead body, and the body of a guard named Julius Martialis, whom they claimed murdered the emperor before they in turn killed him. A lot of people believed that Martialis was a hit man acting on orders from Macrinus, for Macrinus now became the next emperor.

The change in Western rulers saved the day for the Parthians. Artabanus invaded Roman Mesopotamia and destroyed several cities; he crowned an anti-Roman king, Tiridates II, in Armenia. Macrinus sued for peace, agreeing early in 218 to surrender his prisoners and pay an indemnity of 200 million sestertii. This was too much for the troops. Julia Maesa, the sister-in-law of Septimius Severus, enlisted army support for her fourteen-year-old grandson, Varius Avitus Bassianus, better known to us as Elagabalus. A battle near Antioch ended in a rebel victory, and soon after that the fleeing Macrinus was captured and put to death. Elagabalus then went to Rome to claim his prize; his reign is remembered as a four-year-long orgy (218-222), ending when the soldiers turned against him and killed him, too.

The End of the Parthians

One kinglet who declared himself against the Arsacid dynasty was Ardashir of Persis. Persis was the home of the first Persian empire; its main city at this time, Istakhr, was only a few miles from Pasargadae and Persepolis, where one could see the still-impressive ruins of the Achaemenid era. More recently, Persis had been an insignificant province under the Parthians. Ardashir's grandfather, Sassan, presided over a threadbare court and served as a priest in a local temple of Anahita, a water goddess from pre-Zoroastrian days; from him the Persian royal family got the name Sassanid or Sassanian. Sassan's son Papak fulfilled the same duties, and bequeathed the crown to his eldest son, Shapur, but Shapur soon died in an accident and his brother Ardashir took his place (208). Papak had long been preparing a revolt; now Ardashir declared it openly.

Ardashir sought to enlist the other warlords by reminding them of Persia's proud past. Negotiating when he could, fighting when he had to, he won the support of the nearest provinces: Kerman, Isfahan, Elymais, and Charax. Because of the struggle between the Parthian kings, or maybe because of their weakness, Artabanus V did not accuse Ardashir of rebellion until 223. By then, Ardashir was too strong to stop with mere words. "God gave me this throne and this crown," he thundered. "I hope that I will be victorious over you, too, and take your head." Three battles between the Parthians and Persians followed; in the third, at Hormizdagan (224), Artabanus was killed. Two years later, Ardashir reached Ctesiphon, and had himself crowned under the ancient Iranian title "King of Kings." Five and a half centuries after the fall of the first Persian Empire, a king who claimed direct descent from the first Persian kings had restored their civilization.

2. Two first-century historians, Philo and Josephus, reported on events from the administration of Pontius Pilate. When he first became governor, Pilate moved the headquarters of the local garrison from Caesarea to Jerusalem. The soldiers, of course, took their standards with them, bearing images of the Imperial Roman eagle and Emperor Tiberius. The sight of these standards in the holy city enraged the Jews, and they declared they would rather die than have these "idols" displayed within sight of the temple. Since Pilate's most important task was keeping the peace, he agreed to remove the standards.
There were two other occasions when Pilate nearly drove the Jews to insurrection. Once he hung up some golden shields in his palace that were inscribed with the names of pagan gods, and even though the Jews protested, he did not take them down until Tiberius sent an order to do so. Later he built a 25-mile-long aqueduct to bring water from a mountain spring to Jerusalem, and paid for it with funds from the temple treasury. Jewish protests were met by force, and many Jews died; this could have been the incident referred to in Luke 13:1.
Josephus was the only historian of the day who bothered to mention that Pilate presided over the trial of Jesus (Antiquities XVIII:III:3), which goes to show that even reporters and historians can miss the most important events happening in their lifetimes!

3. There was another change in the Church as a result of the missionary work. Jesus had called himself "the Good Shepherd", and used parables about farming or fishing to describe the kingdom of God, but before long Christianity became an urban religion, because the Apostles always founded new churches in the cities, expecting them to convert the people in the surrounding countryside later on. When it came to getting lots of new believers quickly, this was the right strategy.

4. The Romans also finished off the Edomites/Idumaeans, because they joined the Jews in the rebellion. According to Josephus, 20,000 of them were in Jerusalem when the siege began, and they turned against their allies, embarking on a wave of looting and murder. Nevertheless, Titus obliterated them afterwards; only a few refugees escaped. The survivors were absorbed into the local Arab tribes and disappear from history.

5. The Bar Kochba revolt also brought an end, for all practical purposes, to Jewish Christianity. Since the Jewish-Roman War, the Jerusalem Christians had been living in the little town of Pella, east of the Jordan. Now that they could no longer even visit the Holy City, they voted to become Gentiles so they could move into Aelia Capitolina. A minority faction, however, refused to forsake their heritage, and they received the title of Ebionites, a derogatory term meaning paupers. Mainstream Christians later denounced the Ebionites as heretics, because they viewed Jesus as a man filled with God's spirit at his baptism, rather than as the son of God. The Ebionites straddled the fence until the fourth century, when the polarization between Judaism and Christianity caused them to melt away either into churches or synagogues.

6. Glassblowing as we know it was invented in the first century A.D., and it brought the price of glass utensils down to the point where middle-class families could afford them. However, prices stayed high for the complex milleflori and cameo pieces of the Alexandrian master craftsmen. The Emperor Marcus Aurelius collected cameos, and later sold the collection to finance his campaign against the Marcomanni, a German tribe.

7. Hatra beat off the Romans with two unconventional weapons. The first involved the most important resource of the modern Middle East--petroleum. Hatra's defenders would gather crude oil from the local oilfields, and set it on fire before dumping it on the Romans. This burning liquid incinerated people and melted armor easily, and because the Roman Empire did not have this stuff, the Romans found out the hard way that oil fires cannot be put out with water. The other weapon was biological--clay pots filled with live scorpions. Much of the effect of the "scorpion bomb" was psychological; the thought that a pot might break on your head and release the scorpions was enough to make soldiers want to leave before they got stung.

Support this site!